Best barbell row alternatives and variations

The barbell row is one of the most effective back exercises in any program. It’s also one of the most fatiguing, technically demanding, and easy to cheat on.

On 5x5, the barbell row is one of the five core exercises programmed every Workout A for good reason: it builds the upper back, lats, rear delts, and biceps while training the hip hinge position that carries over to your deadlift. But sometimes you need an alternative - whether that’s due to lower back fatigue, mobility limitations, or just working around an injury.

Here’s every meaningful barbell row alternative, when to use each one, and when to stick with the original.

Why the barbell row is in the program

Before exploring alternatives, understand what the barbell row does that other exercises might not.

The bent-over barbell row is a heavy compound pull. It trains:

• Lats and upper back through horizontal pulling
• Rear deltoids which balance all the pressing in 5x5
• Biceps as secondary movers
• Lower back and core isometrically (holding the bent-over position)
• Hip hinge pattern which directly reinforces your deadlift positioning

That last point is often overlooked. The bent-over position of the barbell row is essentially a static deadlift. Your lower back and hamstrings hold you in place while your upper body pulls. This builds the positional strength and endurance that keep your back flat during heavy deadlifts.

Any alternative you choose should aim to replicate as many of these benefits as possible. For perfect barbell row setup and execution, start with the barbell row technique guide.

Pendlay row

The Pendlay row is less an alternative and more a stricter version of the barbell row. Named after Olympic weightlifting coach Glenn Pendlay, it starts from the floor each rep.

How to do it

1. Set up exactly like a standard barbell row: feet shoulder width, grip just outside your knees, torso roughly parallel to the floor
2. Let the bar rest on the floor between each rep - dead stop, no touch-and-go
3. Row the bar explosively to your lower chest
4. Lower the bar back to the floor with control
5. Reset your position before each rep

Pros

• Eliminates momentum. Each rep starts from zero, so you can’t cheat with body English.
• Enforces consistent form. The dead stop makes you set up properly every rep, similar to how each deadlift rep starts from the floor.
• Builds explosive pulling power. The dead-stop start requires you to generate force quickly, which has carryover to deadlifts and cleans.
• Easy to program. Uses a barbell, loads the same way, progresses the same way as standard rows.

Cons

• Slightly less time under tension. The dead stop means less eccentric loading compared to touch-and-go rows.
• Requires good hip hinge mobility. Your torso needs to be close to parallel for each rep, which is demanding on hamstring flexibility.
• Usually lighter than standard rows. Eliminating momentum means you’ll use less weight. This is a feature, not a bug.

When to use it

If you tend to cheat your barbell rows (standing too upright, using momentum, bouncing the bar off your stomach), switch to Pendlay rows. They enforce the discipline that the standard row allows you to skip.

Dumbbell row

The single-arm dumbbell row is probably the most popular barbell row alternative, and for good reason.

How to do it

1. Place one hand and one knee on a bench for support
2. Hold a dumbbell in the opposite hand, arm hanging straight
3. Row the dumbbell to your hip, pulling your elbow back and up
4. Lower with control
5. Complete all reps on one side, then switch

Pros

• Zero lower back stress. The bench supports your torso entirely. If lower back fatigue from deadlifts is your issue, this solves it completely.
• Unilateral training. Trains each side independently, correcting strength imbalances.
• Greater range of motion. No barbell hitting your chest to limit the pull. You can row higher and get more contraction.
• Easy to learn. The supported position makes it much simpler to feel your back working.

Cons

• No hip hinge demand. You lose the isometric lower back and hamstring work that makes the barbell row carry over to deadlifts.
• Harder to load heavy. Gym dumbbells may not go heavy enough for advanced lifters. Holding a very heavy dumbbell with one hand becomes a grip challenge.
• Takes longer. You’re doing each side separately, so the exercise takes roughly twice as long.

When to use it

When lower back recovery is a problem. If you’re doing heavy squats and deadlifts and your lower back is always fried for rows, dumbbell rows let you train your upper back without adding more lower back fatigue. They’re also excellent as an accessory exercise after your barbell rows.

Cable row (seated)

The seated cable row provides constant tension throughout the movement and removes lower back loading almost entirely.

How to do it

1. Sit at a cable row station with your feet on the platform, knees slightly bent
2. Grab the handle (V-grip, wide grip, or straight bar)
3. Sit upright with a slight lean forward
4. Row the handle to your lower chest/upper abdomen
5. Squeeze your shoulder blades together at the peak
6. Return with control, allowing a slight stretch

Pros

• Constant tension. Unlike barbell rows where the bottom is easy and the top is hard, cables provide resistance throughout the entire range.
• Minimal lower back demand. The seated position and cable angle mean almost zero spinal loading.
• Very adjustable. Change the handle for different grips, adjust the weight in small increments, modify the angle.
• Joint-friendly. The smooth cable path is easier on elbows and shoulders than heavy barbell rows.

Cons

• Hard to progressively overload. Cable stacks go up in larger increments and are harder to track linearly compared to barbell loading.
• No hip hinge pattern. Completely removes the lower back and hamstring isometric component.
• Different stimulus. The constant tension is great for muscle building but doesn’t replicate the strength demand of pulling a heavy bar from a bent-over position.
• Harder to go truly heavy. The seated position limits how much load you can handle compared to a standing bent-over row.

When to use it

As a secondary rowing movement or during deload periods. Cable rows are excellent for building upper back muscle volume without systemic fatigue. They’re less appropriate as a primary row replacement on a strength program because progressive overload is harder to implement.

T-bar row

The T-bar row is a middle ground between barbell rows and machine rows. It allows heavy loading with a more stable path than free-weight rows.

How to do it

With a dedicated T-bar station:

1. Straddle the platform, grip the handles
2. Bend at the hips, torso at roughly 45 degrees
3. Row the weight to your chest
4. Lower with control

With a barbell in a landmine or corner:

1. Wedge one end of a barbell in a corner or landmine attachment
2. Load the other end with plates
3. Straddle the bar, grip it with a V-grip handle or interlocked hands under the plates
4. Row the loaded end to your chest

Pros

• Heavy loading possible. The fixed pivot point allows you to row heavy without the balance demands of a free barbell.
• Moderate lower back demand. More than cable rows, less than barbell rows. A good middle ground.
• Comfortable grip. A neutral grip (palms facing each other) is often easier on the shoulders and elbows than the pronated or supinated grip of barbell rows.
• Builds thick upper back. The close grip and heavy loading tend to emphasize the mid-back (rhomboids, mid-traps).

Cons

• Less hip hinge demand than a standard barbell row.
• Fixed bar path. The pivot point dictates the movement arc, which may not suit all body proportions.
• Equipment required. Not every gym has a T-bar station, and landmine setups can be clunky.

When to use it

When you want to row heavy with less lower back concern than barbell rows. T-bar rows are popular among bodybuilders for building back thickness and they work well as either a primary or secondary rowing exercise.

Chest-supported row

The chest-supported row completely eliminates lower back involvement by having you lie face down on an incline bench.

How to do it

1. Set an adjustable bench to 30-45 degrees
2. Lie face down on the bench, feet on the floor for stability
3. Hold dumbbells or a barbell hanging straight down
4. Row the weight to the sides of the bench (dumbbells) or to the underside (barbell)
5. Squeeze at the top, lower with control

Pros

• Zero lower back involvement. The bench supports your entire torso. This is the most lower-back-friendly rowing variation.
• Pure upper back isolation. Without the need to maintain a hip hinge, all your effort goes into the actual rowing movement.
• No cheating possible. You can’t use momentum or body English when your chest is pinned to a bench.
• Great for high-rep work. You can accumulate volume without any systemic fatigue.

Cons

• No hip hinge or core training. Completely removes the isometric demands that make barbell rows a full-body exercise.
• Limited load. Especially with dumbbells, you’ll use significantly less weight than barbell rows.
• Can be uncomfortable. The bench pressing on your chest and stomach is awkward, especially at heavier weights.
• Doesn’t build positional strength. No carryover to maintaining a flat back during deadlifts.

When to use it

When recovery is the priority and you want to train your upper back without any cost to your lower back. Chest-supported rows are ideal during periods of high squat and deadlift volume, after an injury, or as high-rep accessory work after your main rowing.

Inverted rows (bodyweight rows)

For beginners who can’t yet row an empty barbell with good form, or for anyone wanting a warm-up or burnout set.

How to do it

1. Set a barbell in a rack at about waist height (or use a Smith machine)
2. Hang underneath the bar with arms extended, body straight from heels to shoulders
3. Pull your chest to the bar
4. Lower with control
5. Keep your body in a straight line throughout

Pros

• Perfect for beginners. No equipment knowledge needed, easy to learn, builds the pulling pattern.
• Adjustable difficulty. Raise the bar to make it easier, lower it to make it harder. Bend your knees to reduce difficulty or elevate your feet to increase it.
• Builds good habits. The straight body position teaches core engagement and full-range pulling.
• Zero spinal loading. Completely bodyweight, no compressive forces on the spine.

Cons

• Limited load progression. Once you can do 15+ reps, you need external resistance or a harder variation.
• Doesn’t scale for advanced lifters. Not heavy enough to build meaningful strength past the beginner stage.
• Not a true replacement. Missing the heavy loading, hip hinge, and progressive overload that make barbell rows valuable on 5x5.

When to use it

As a stepping stone to barbell rows. If you can’t maintain a flat back while rowing the empty bar, spend a few weeks building strength with inverted rows. Once you can do 3x10 with your body close to horizontal, try barbell rows again.

Also useful as a warm-up before heavy rows or as a finisher at the end of a back session.

How to choose the right alternative

Decision framework

Lower back fatigue is the problem: Dumbbell rows or chest-supported rows. These eliminate spinal loading entirely.

You cheat your barbell rows: Switch to Pendlay rows. The dead stop eliminates momentum.

You want more back volume without extra fatigue: Add cable rows or chest-supported rows as accessories after your main rows.

You’re a beginner who can’t row the bar: Start with inverted rows and progress to barbell rows.

You want to row heavy but your lower back is the limiter: T-bar rows allow heavy loading with less lower back demand.

You have a shoulder or elbow issue: Cable rows with a neutral grip handle are usually the most joint-friendly option.

When to stick with the barbell row

Most of the time. The barbell row is in the 5x5 program because it’s the best overall back exercise for strength development alongside squats and deadlifts. The hip hinge position, the progressive loading, and the full-body demand make it irreplaceable for most trainees.

If you’re substituting because rows feel hard or uncomfortable, that’s not a reason to switch. The bent-over position is supposed to be demanding. That demand is what builds the positional strength that carries over to every other lift.

If you’re substituting because of genuine recovery issues, injury, or mobility limitations, the alternatives above will keep your back training on track until you can return to barbell rows.

Programming alternatives on 5x5

If you do substitute, keep the sets and reps the same: 5x5 for your primary rowing movement. Use the same progressive overload principles. Add weight when you complete all sets and reps with good form.

For accessories added after your main row, 3x8-12 is a good range. Pick one rowing variation as your main movement and one as an accessory at most. More than that is unnecessary volume for a lifter on 5x5.

The barbell row is the default. Review the complete exercise guide to understand how rows fit into the full program. Choose an alternative only when you have a clear reason. And when that reason resolves, go back to the barbell.

Track your rowing progression and all your 5x5 lifts in one place:

Download Lift5x5 free →